Kansas the best way to counterclaim crossclaim eviction process: Navigating the complexities of eviction instances in Kansas can really feel daunting. This complete information breaks down the steps, offering readability and empowering tenants with the information to successfully reply to eviction notices. Discover ways to craft compelling counterclaims and crossclaims, perceive timelines, and maximize your authorized choices.
From non-payment to lease violations, this information Artikels the various kinds of eviction instances in Kansas, detailing the particular procedures for every. It covers the vital roles of landlords and tenants, authorized cures, and the important paperwork wanted all through the method.
Eviction Procedures in Kansas
Salam sejahtera! Understanding the eviction course of in Kansas is essential for each landlords and tenants. This dialogue will element the steps concerned, timelines, required paperwork, sorts of instances, roles of events, and authorized cures out there. Semoga informasi ini bermanfaat bagi semua pihak.The eviction course of in Kansas, like many different states, is designed to guard the rights of each landlords and tenants whereas making certain a good and simply decision to disputes.
This framework Artikels the procedures to observe when a landlord seeks to evict a tenant, and the recourse out there to a tenant going through eviction.
Eviction Course of Steps
The Kansas eviction course of sometimes entails a number of steps, from preliminary discover to court docket proceedings. It is essential for each events to stick to the established procedures to make sure a easy and legally sound decision.
- Discover to Vacate: The owner should present a proper written discover to the tenant specifying the explanation for eviction, and the required date for vacating the premises. This discover sometimes Artikels the grounds for eviction, corresponding to non-payment of lease or breach of lease settlement. The required timeframes for this discover differ primarily based on the explanation for eviction, with non-payment requiring a selected variety of days’ discover.
- Submitting an Eviction Swimsuit: If the tenant doesn’t vacate the property after the discover interval, the owner should file an eviction lawsuit within the applicable Kansas district court docket. This entails finishing particular kinds and offering supporting paperwork to substantiate the eviction declare. The paperwork will embrace the discover to vacate and any related lease agreements.
- Court docket Listening to: A court docket listening to is scheduled to find out if the eviction is justified. Each events have the chance to current their case, present proof, and query witnesses. The court docket will take into account the proof and arguments introduced by each events.
- Court docket Order: If the court docket guidelines in favor of the owner, it points an order for eviction. This order will set a date for the tenant to vacate the premises. The tenant is usually given a selected variety of days to adjust to the court docket order. Failure to conform can lead to additional authorized motion.
- Writ of Restitution: If the tenant nonetheless doesn’t adjust to the court docket order, the owner can acquire a Writ of Restitution. This court docket order permits legislation enforcement to bodily take away the tenant from the property. That is the ultimate step within the eviction course of.
Timelines in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
The timelines related to every step of the eviction course of in Kansas are essential for each events. Adhering to those timelines is vital for sustaining the legality and effectivity of the method.
- Discover to Vacate: Timeframes differ relying on the explanation for eviction. For non-payment, a selected variety of days’ discover is required. Failure to observe the right timeframes can invalidate the eviction course of.
- Submitting and Court docket Hearings: The precise timeframe for submitting the eviction go well with and scheduling the listening to varies by jurisdiction and the court docket’s schedule. Court docket delays can affect the general timeline of the method.
- Writ of Restitution: The issuance of a Writ of Restitution is usually expedited after the court docket has dominated in favor of the owner and the tenant has didn’t adjust to the court docket order.
Required Paperwork and Kinds
The required paperwork and kinds for initiating an eviction case in Kansas are standardized. Each events ought to pay attention to these necessities to make sure compliance.
- Lease Settlement: The lease settlement is a vital doc in any eviction case, outlining the phrases and circumstances of the tenancy.
- Discover to Vacate: A proper discover to vacate, outlining the explanation for eviction and the required date for vacating the property, is essential.
- Eviction Criticism Kinds: Particular kinds have to be accomplished and filed with the court docket, offering particulars concerning the eviction case.
- Supporting Paperwork: Any supporting paperwork, corresponding to lease receipts or proof of lease violations, ought to be submitted with the criticism.
Sorts of Eviction Circumstances in Kansas
Eviction instances in Kansas may be categorized into varied varieties, every with its particular procedures.
- Non-Cost of Lease: This can be a frequent motive for eviction, the place the tenant fails to pay lease as agreed upon within the lease settlement.
- Breach of Lease Settlement: This encompasses violations of the lease phrases, corresponding to failure to take care of the property or participating in unlawful actions. Particular cases of breach, corresponding to damaging the property or permitting unauthorized occupancy, ought to be clearly documented.
Landlord and Tenant Duties
Landlords and tenants have particular roles and obligations within the Kansas eviction course of. Understanding these obligations is important for a good and efficient course of.
- Landlords: Landlords should adhere to authorized procedures, present correct discover, and doc the explanations for eviction precisely. They need to current all essential documentation to the court docket.
- Tenants: Tenants have the fitting to defend themselves in opposition to the eviction and may reply appropriately to the discover to vacate. They need to additionally pay attention to their rights and obligations within the authorized course of.
Counterclaims in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
Salam! Understanding counterclaims in Kansas eviction instances is essential for tenants. A counterclaim permits tenants to current their aspect of the story, probably addressing points that led to the eviction discover and even searching for compensation for damages or different losses. This part will delve into the sorts of counterclaims, defenses, submitting necessities, profitable examples, potential outcomes, and the process for submitting them.
Let’s navigate this course of collectively.In Kansas eviction proceedings, tenants have the fitting to current counterclaims. This implies they can’t solely defend in opposition to the eviction but in addition assert claims in opposition to the owner. A well-prepared counterclaim can considerably affect the result of the case.
Sorts of Counterclaims in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
Tenants can file varied counterclaims in Kansas eviction proceedings. These could embrace claims for unpaid lease, property injury, and breaches of the lease settlement. Understanding the varied claims is crucial for tenants to successfully current their case. These claims typically stem from the owner’s actions or inactions that violated the lease or tenant’s rights.
Defenses within the Type of Counterclaims
Tenants can use counterclaims as defenses in an eviction case. These defenses can come up from the owner’s failure to take care of the property, harassment, or retaliatory eviction. For example, a landlord’s failure to make essential repairs may very well be a protection in a counterclaim.
Necessities for Submitting a Counterclaim in a Kansas Eviction Case
To file a counterclaim in a Kansas eviction case, tenants should observe particular procedures. This features a well timed submitting of the counterclaim with the court docket and compliance with the court docket’s guidelines. The counterclaim have to be correctly documented, exhibiting the character of the declare and its connection to the eviction case. This detailed documentation helps the tenant’s argument in opposition to the eviction.
Examples of Profitable Counterclaims
Whereas particular case particulars can’t be supplied, profitable counterclaims in Kansas eviction instances typically contain points like the owner’s failure to offer important utilities or a violation of the lease settlement. For example, a landlord’s failure to offer a functioning heating system throughout winter may result in a profitable counterclaim. One other instance may contain the owner’s failure to return a safety deposit, a typical supply of tenant counterclaims.
Potential Outcomes of a Counterclaim
The end result of a counterclaim in a Kansas eviction case can differ. A tenant could obtain compensation for damages or a dismissal of the eviction case. Profitable counterclaims may even result in a judgment in opposition to the owner, impacting their future actions within the rental market. Tenants want to know the potential outcomes and put together accordingly.
Process for Submitting a Counterclaim in Kansas Eviction Court docket
The process for submitting a counterclaim in Kansas eviction court docket entails submitting the counterclaim with the suitable court docket paperwork, following particular deadlines, and probably participating in discovery to collect proof. This entails cautious preparation and adhering to the court docket’s directions to make sure the counterclaim is correctly introduced.
Variations Between a Counterclaim and a Crossclaim
A counterclaim is a declare by a defendant in opposition to a plaintiff in the identical case. A crossclaim is a declare by one defendant in opposition to one other defendant in the identical case. The important thing distinction lies within the events concerned. A counterclaim addresses the plaintiff’s preliminary declare, whereas a crossclaim targets one other defendant inside the case. Understanding this distinction is essential for tenants to correctly body their authorized motion.
Crossclaims in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
Salam, semoga semuanya baik-baik saja. Understanding crossclaims in Kansas eviction instances is essential for each landlords and tenants. A crossclaim permits a celebration in an eviction continuing to convey a separate declare in opposition to one other get together in the identical case, fairly than submitting a separate lawsuit. This could streamline the method and probably resolve a number of points directly.
Let’s delve into the small print.Crossclaims in Kansas eviction proceedings are a robust software, permitting events to deal with associated claims inside the identical authorized framework. They supply a method for resolving disputes arising from the identical transaction or occasion, corresponding to damages or breach of contract, which might be immediately related to the underlying eviction case. It is essential to know when a crossclaim is acceptable and the way it differs from a counterclaim.
Understanding Crossclaims
A crossclaim is a declare introduced by a celebration in a case in opposition to one other get together who’s already concerned in the identical authorized motion. In an eviction case, a crossclaim would possibly come up when a landlord claims the tenant broken the property past regular put on and tear, and the tenant asserts that the owner failed to take care of the property in livable circumstances.
Each claims are associated to the tenancy and the eviction continuing.
Conditions for Crossclaims in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
Crossclaims are applicable when the declare arises from the identical transaction or incidence as the primary case. This implies the declare immediately pertains to the tenancy, the alleged breach of contract, or the occasions main as much as the eviction. For instance, if a landlord is searching for eviction for non-payment of lease, the tenant may file a crossclaim alleging the owner didn’t make essential repairs, which affected their capacity to pay lease.
Examples of Crossclaims
- A tenant would possibly file a crossclaim in opposition to the owner for unpaid safety deposit if the owner’s declare is for non-payment of lease.
- A landlord would possibly file a crossclaim in opposition to a tenant for damages exceeding regular put on and tear.
- If a tenant claims constructive eviction as a result of an absence of essential repairs, the owner may file a crossclaim for unpaid lease.
Authorized Grounds for Submitting a Crossclaim
Authorized grounds for a crossclaim are these immediately associated to the underlying eviction case. This might contain breach of contract, violation of lease phrases, property injury, or claims for damages incurred as a result of eviction itself. For instance, if a tenant claims the owner’s actions led to a lack of revenue, they could cite a violation of the lease because the authorized foundation for his or her crossclaim.
Crossclaims vs. Counterclaims
Whereas each crossclaims and counterclaims enable a celebration to claim a declare in opposition to one other get together in a case, they differ of their utility. A counterclaim asserts a declare in opposition to the get together initiating the primary lawsuit, whereas a crossclaim asserts a declare in opposition to a co-party. A counterclaim seeks to fully negate the unique declare, whereas a crossclaim goals to deal with a associated declare arising from the identical incidence.
| Attribute | Counterclaim | Crossclaim |
|---|---|---|
| Social gathering Towards | The get together initiating the lawsuit | One other get together in the identical lawsuit |
| Goal | To negate the unique declare | To deal with a associated declare |
| Relationship to Principal Declare | May be unrelated or oppose the unique declare | Should be immediately associated to the primary declare |
Process for Submitting a Crossclaim, Kansas the best way to counterclaim crossclaim eviction process
The process for submitting a crossclaim in Kansas eviction court docket follows the foundations of civil process. It sometimes entails submitting a separate doc with the court docket, detailing the declare, proof, and authorized arguments. This ought to be carried out inside the prescribed timeframe Artikeld by the court docket.
Potential Outcomes of a Crossclaim
The end result of a crossclaim is dependent upon the particular details of the case and the court docket’s choice. The court docket will weigh the proof introduced by each events and render a judgment on the crossclaim. This judgment would possibly embrace financial compensation, or an order to carry out or chorus from particular actions. It is essential to notice {that a} profitable crossclaim does not essentially negate the unique eviction declare.
Defenses and Cures for Tenants
Salam, fellow Minangs! Understanding your rights as a tenant in Kansas is essential for navigating potential conflicts with landlords. This part will delve into frequent defenses tenants can use, examples of landlord misconduct, and the cures out there to tenants who efficiently problem these violations. We may also Artikel tenant rights and the authorized necessities for proving a landlord’s wrongdoing.Landlords and tenants typically have completely different interpretations of the settlement.
Understanding the nuances of Kansas tenant legal guidelines is important to guard your pursuits. This information empowers you to confidently assert your rights and navigate eviction proceedings with higher assurance.
Frequent Defenses in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
Figuring out potential defenses is vital to a profitable protection in an eviction case. Listed here are some frequent defenses tenants can increase in Kansas eviction court docket:
- The owner didn’t correctly observe the authorized procedures for initiating the eviction case. This consists of making certain the right notices have been served and deadlines met.
- The owner violated the phrases of the lease settlement, corresponding to by making unauthorized repairs or not offering important companies like water or warmth.
- The owner retaliated in opposition to the tenant for exercising their authorized rights, corresponding to reporting housing code violations.
- The owner didn’t adjust to the discover necessities underneath Kansas legislation for repairs, and the situation of the premises affected the tenant’s well being and security.
Examples of Landlord Misconduct in Kansas
Landlords generally act in ways in which violate tenant rights in Kansas. Listed here are some examples:
- Failing to make essential repairs: A landlord could ignore a tenant’s requests to repair a leaky roof or damaged plumbing, probably making a hazardous residing state of affairs. This violation can be utilized as a protection in an eviction case.
- Retaliation for complaints: If a tenant experiences a essential restore or housing code violation to the correct authorities, the owner can’t evict the tenant in retaliation. This can be a important safety for tenants in Kansas.
- Improper discover of termination: Landlords should observe exact procedures for terminating a lease. Failing to take action may invalidate the eviction discover.
- Unlawful discrimination: A landlord can’t discriminate in opposition to a tenant primarily based on race, faith, or different protected traits. This can be a severe violation with extreme penalties for the owner.
Potential Cures for Tenants
Tenants who efficiently defend in opposition to an eviction have a number of doable cures. These cures goal to compensate for the owner’s violations.
- Court docket order to dismiss the eviction case: The court docket can order the dismissal of the eviction lawsuit if the owner failed to satisfy the required procedures.
- Reimbursement for damages and bills: The tenant could also be awarded compensation for bills incurred as a result of landlord’s misconduct, corresponding to the price of discovering different housing or the price of repairs the tenant made to the premises.
- Injunction to forestall additional motion: The court docket could challenge an injunction to cease the owner from taking additional actions that violate tenant rights.
Authorized Recourse Towards a Landlord
Tenants have authorized choices to deal with landlord misconduct. Initiating authorized motion is crucial for safeguarding your rights and making certain honest therapy.
- File a lawsuit: Tenants can file a lawsuit in opposition to a landlord for violations of Kansas tenant legal guidelines.
- Search authorized counsel: Consulting a lawyer is strongly really useful for steerage on pursuing authorized recourse and the particular authorized procedures in your state of affairs.
- Mediation: Mediation generally is a extra amicable solution to resolve disputes with the owner and keep away from going to court docket.
Tenant Rights in Kansas Eviction Circumstances
This desk summarizes some key tenant rights in Kansas eviction instances. It is essential to notice that this isn’t an exhaustive checklist, and particular circumstances could have an effect on the applicability of those rights.
| Tenant Proper | Description |
|---|---|
| Proper to a good listening to | Tenants have the fitting to a listening to to current their case and defenses. |
| Proper to authorized counsel | Tenants have the fitting to be represented by an legal professional. |
| Proper to be notified of the eviction proceedings | Landlords should observe correct procedures for serving eviction notices to tenants. |
| Safety in opposition to retaliation | Tenants are protected against retaliatory evictions for exercising their rights. |
Authorized Necessities for Proving Landlord Misconduct
To efficiently problem a landlord’s actions in a Kansas eviction case, tenants should show that the owner violated Kansas tenant legal guidelines.
- Proof of violation: This consists of documentation corresponding to lease agreements, restore requests, and notices.
- Clear and convincing proof: Tenants should present sufficient proof to display that the owner acted improperly. This would possibly contain witness testimony, photographs, and different supporting proof.
- Correct documentation: Preserving data of communications and interactions with the owner is important to construct a powerful case.
Process for Submitting a Counterclaim or Crossclaim: Kansas How To Counterclaim Crossclaim Eviction Process
Salam, Bapak/Ibu. Understanding the procedures for submitting a counterclaim or crossclaim in a Kansas eviction case is essential for tenants going through eviction. This part will element the steps concerned, the required paperwork, and deadlines, making certain a easy and knowledgeable course of.Submitting a counterclaim or crossclaim permits tenants to current their aspect of the story, probably negating the owner’s declare and even acquiring a good judgment.
Figuring out the steps concerned will empower tenants to navigate this course of successfully.
Particular Steps for Submitting a Counterclaim
To provoke a counterclaim in a Kansas eviction case, the tenant should first file a doc referred to as a “counterclaim” with the court docket. This doc Artikels the tenant’s causes for disputing the eviction, stating their grievances and searching for cures. The counterclaim have to be particular and well-supported by proof. This doc normally consists of particulars concerning the nature of the dispute, the damages incurred by the tenant, and the requested reduction.
Needed Paperwork and Deadlines for Submitting a Counterclaim
The required paperwork consists of the counterclaim itself, together with supporting paperwork like receipts, photographs, and witness statements. The deadlines for submitting a counterclaim are essential; failing to satisfy these deadlines can lead to the court docket dismissing the counterclaim. It is essential to seek the advice of with a authorized skilled to find out the particular deadlines for the jurisdiction the place the case is filed.
The court docket will sometimes have a selected process for submitting these paperwork, and these procedures will should be adopted meticulously. Late submitting can lead to dismissal.
Serving the Counterclaim on the Opposing Social gathering
Correct service of the counterclaim on the owner is important. This entails delivering a replica of the counterclaim to the owner, or their authorized consultant, in a way prescribed by Kansas legislation. Strategies of service can embrace private service, substituted service, or service by publication. It’s endorsed to hunt skilled steerage on the very best technique to make use of in a selected case.
Particular Steps for Submitting a Crossclaim
A crossclaim in an eviction case permits a tenant to convey a declare in opposition to a 3rd get together, corresponding to one other tenant or a property supervisor. The tenant must file a doc with the court docket referred to as a “crossclaim.” This doc Artikels the tenant’s grievances in opposition to the third get together. It ought to be as detailed as doable. It should specify the explanation for the declare, the damages incurred, and the requested reduction.
Serving a Crossclaim on the Opposing Social gathering
The method for serving a crossclaim is much like serving a counterclaim, requiring adherence to Kansas’ guidelines of civil process. The court docket can have particular necessities for serving the crossclaim on the third get together. It is essential to make sure correct service to keep away from potential points later within the proceedings.
Abstract Desk of Submitting and Serving Counterclaims and Crossclaims
| Process | Steps |
|---|---|
| Submitting a Counterclaim | Put together and file a counterclaim with the court docket. Embody supporting paperwork. Adhere to deadlines. |
| Serving a Counterclaim | Serve a replica of the counterclaim on the owner or their authorized consultant utilizing a technique accredited by Kansas legislation. |
| Submitting a Crossclaim | Put together and file a crossclaim with the court docket in opposition to a 3rd get together. Embody supporting paperwork. |
| Serving a Crossclaim | Serve a replica of the crossclaim on the third get together in accordance with Kansas’ guidelines of civil process. |
Kansas Eviction Case Timeline and Deadlines
Salam kenal, fellow Minangkabaus! Understanding the timeline and deadlines in a Kansas eviction case is essential for each landlords and tenants. Figuring out the steps and timeframes concerned may help you navigate the method easily and keep away from potential pitfalls. Let’s delve into the specifics.This part will Artikel the everyday development of a Kansas eviction case, from the preliminary discover to the ultimate judgment, together with the related deadlines and procedures for extending them.
We may also discover potential delays and their affect on the general timeline. This complete overview goals to offer a transparent roadmap for all events concerned.
Typical Development of a Kansas Eviction Case
The eviction course of in Kansas sometimes follows a structured sequence, beginning with the discover to vacate and culminating in a court docket judgment. Every stage has particular deadlines that have to be adhered to. Failure to satisfy these deadlines can have important penalties.
- Discover to Vacate: The owner should present the tenant with a proper discover to vacate, specifying the explanations for the eviction and the required move-out date. This discover is a vital first step, because it initiates the authorized course of. The precise kind of discover required (e.g., for non-payment of lease, breach of lease) will have an effect on the timeline.
- Submitting of Eviction Swimsuit: If the tenant fails to vacate after the discover interval, the owner recordsdata an eviction lawsuit with the suitable Kansas court docket. This submitting triggers the formal court docket proceedings. The tenant have to be correctly served with the lawsuit paperwork, which is a vital step for the case to proceed.
- Answering the Eviction Swimsuit: The tenant has a selected timeframe to answer the lawsuit. This response would possibly contain submitting a solution, counterclaim, or cross-claim. This stage permits the tenant to current their aspect of the story and potential defenses.
- Discovery Interval: Each events can collect proof, conduct interviews, and procure paperwork related to the case throughout the discovery interval. This can be a important step for either side to arrange their arguments and probably settle the matter exterior of court docket.
- Pre-Trial Motions: Both get together can file motions earlier than the trial to deal with procedural or authorized points. These motions may embrace requests for extensions of time, motions to dismiss, or different authorized challenges.
- Trial: If the case does not settle, it’ll proceed to trial. In the course of the trial, either side current their proof and arguments. The decide or jury will decide primarily based on the introduced proof.
- Judgment and Order: The court docket points a judgment, which both orders the tenant to vacate the premises or dismisses the eviction case. The judgment additionally sometimes Artikels the fee obligations for damages and court docket prices.
- Enforcement of the Judgment: If the tenant fails to adjust to the judgment, the owner can search enforcement by means of the court docket system, which could embrace a writ of possession to take away the tenant from the property.
Deadlines and Time Limits
Particular deadlines for every stage of the Kansas eviction course of are essential. Failure to stick to those deadlines can affect the result of the case. Kansas legislation Artikels the particular timeframes for every stage.
| Stage | Description | Typical Timeframe |
|---|---|---|
| Discover to Vacate | Landlord gives discover to tenant to vacate. | Typically, 3-14 days relying on the explanation for eviction. |
| Submitting of Eviction Swimsuit | Landlord recordsdata lawsuit with the court docket. | Inside a selected timeframe after the discover interval. |
| Answering the Eviction Swimsuit | Tenant responds to the lawsuit. | A prescribed variety of days after being served with the lawsuit. |
| Discovery | Gathering proof and data. | Court docket-determined timeframe, typically versatile with extensions. |
| Trial | Presentation of proof and arguments. | Scheduled by the court docket. |
| Judgment | Court docket renders a call. | Following the trial. |
Extending Deadlines
Extensions of deadlines in Kansas eviction instances are doable however require a proper request to the court docket.
A celebration should display a sound motive for the request and observe the prescribed process. Court docket guidelines normally require offering enough discover to the opposing get together. Particular necessities differ primarily based on the character of the extension request.
Potential Delays
A number of elements may cause delays in Kansas eviction instances, together with advanced authorized points, the necessity for added discovery, or the unavailability of key witnesses. These delays can considerably affect the general timeline. For instance, a tenant disputing the explanations for eviction would possibly result in in depth authorized proceedings. A sudden sickness of a witness may result in postponement of the trial date.
Every state of affairs ought to be addressed individually, and the court docket’s guidelines for dealing with delays have to be adhered to.
Final Phrase
In conclusion, mastering the nuances of Kansas eviction counterclaims and crossclaims equips tenants with the instruments to defend their rights. This information gives a sensible roadmap for understanding the procedures, timelines, and potential outcomes, empowering tenants to navigate these difficult authorized waters with confidence. Keep in mind, searching for authorized counsel is all the time really useful for personalised recommendation tailor-made to your particular circumstances.
FAQ Part
What are the frequent defenses tenants can increase in a Kansas eviction case?
Frequent defenses embrace landlord violations of Kansas tenant legal guidelines, corresponding to failing to offer important companies (e.g., warmth, water), retaliatory evictions, or failure to adjust to correct discover procedures.
How lengthy does the eviction course of sometimes soak up Kansas?
The timeline varies primarily based on the particular circumstances and court docket procedures. Nonetheless, a typical Kansas eviction case can take a number of weeks to months, ranging from the preliminary discover and probably extending to court docket hearings and appeals.
What are the potential cures for tenants who efficiently defend in opposition to an eviction?
Profitable defenses would possibly lead to dismissal of the eviction case, or a court docket order requiring the owner to deal with the violations. In some cases, tenants is likely to be awarded compensation for damages or authorized charges.
What are the important thing variations between a counterclaim and a crossclaim in a Kansas eviction case?
A counterclaim is a declare by the tenant in opposition to the owner arising from the identical incident or occasion that kinds the premise of the eviction. A crossclaim, then again, is a declare by one get together in opposition to one other get together in the identical case, typically between co-defendants or co-plaintiffs.
